If you want a list of obvious answers and people who aren’t actually overrated, then go look somewhere else. But if you want to know my picks for players who everyone fawns over a little too much and who I actually watched play through their careers, then look here.
I’ve seen it all in the NFL. And someone can be a great, even a Hall of Famer, but overrated, either because they won a whole bunch of awards they shouldn’t have or because people gassed them up over more deserving players.
A lot of these 10 players are people I actually rate highly, but I think the general public just gave him too much credit. So let’s get to roasting.
Marshawn Lynch
I’m not sure how a guy who committed a hit-and-run in 2008 and then claimed, “I didn’t know my car had hit anyone or anything,” and then committed two DUIs later on became the most sympathetic character in the NFL during the 2010s. I don’t think he’s a bad guy, necessarily, as his gestures of buying Thanksgiving meals for homeless people and other stories of him bonding with his teammates and the community paint a different picture.
But I do think a lot of the lore of the Skittles, Applebee’s and Dave and Busters, and the whole “I’m just here so I don’t get find schtick” clouded people’s objectivity on Lynch as a player.
He had the “Beast Quake” run and “Beast Quake 2.0” and was a great running back at his peak, and he was actually underrated before he got to Seattle with the Buffalo Bills.
But when you look back at the context of his career, it was gassed up too much. Lynch had four double digit rushing touchdown seasons and four 1,000 yard rushing seasons in a row for the Seattle Seahawks after being a back to back 1,000 yard rusher to begin his career in Buffalo. But by the time 2015 came along, he was washed, and he set the Oakland Raiders organization back.
Lynch was also never an efficient rusher. He had a rushing success rate well below 50 percent for his career and during his peak in Seattle, averaging a career 4.2 yards per carry.
His 2012 season with the Seahawks averaging 5.0 yards per carry with over 1,500 yards was incredible, but I don’t know that one great season and a four-year peak of good seasons makes someone a Hall of Famer.
I also don’t think we criticize him enough for throwing Russell Wilson under the bus for not wanting to talk to his fake nice schtick about rubbing it in that he had a better game against a bad pass defense and a good run defense than Russell did. And I think him not backing Wilson after Pete Carroll’s decision to pass on the goal line shows his character as a teammate. The Seahawks never became a dynasty because they were so immature and complained about one bad decision the coach who helped get them there made, and it’s fitting that the likes of Lynch, Richard Sherman, and the rest did a whole lot of nothing in terms of winning the rest of their careers. Because let’s face it, Lynch was mostly a loser in his career without Wilson and Carroll.
Peyton Manning
If you’ve ever listened to Drew Brees answer the question of why he won so few MVPs in his career despite his greatness, all you have to do is look at the quarterback he embarrassed in the Super Bowl, Peyton Manning. Because you can make a convincing case that Peyton only deserved one or two of the whopping five MVPs he won, as Aaron Rodgers, Tom Brady, and Drew Brees were robbed of multiple awards because voters, again, fell for the “aw schucks” personality of Peyton.
Look, Manning was a great quarterback, no doubt. He is also the worst quarterback to have won a Super Bowl back when the Denver Broncos all time defense carried his corpse and his Wounded Duck throws over the finish line in 2015. Manning has more playoff humiliations than triumphs, mostly at the hands of Brady, and he was pretty grossly overrated during his actual playing career.
No quarterback in NFL history had as great of a supporting cast as him. He played with elite offensive lines during his entire career and the likes of Edgerrin James, Joseph Addai, Dallas Clark, Julius Thomas, Demaryius Thomas, Wes Welker, Marvin Harrison, Brandon Stokely, Reggie Wayne, Eric Decker, Emmanuel Sanders, Austin Collie, and too many others to list. He regularly had good running games, amazing lines, coaching staffs loaded with icons, and four or five targets to throw it to.
And yet many of them have more horror stories about Peyton reaming someone and benching them personally after a drop than they do of him making them better. He treated his best players like disposable parts, priding himself in throwing Hospital Balls for completions, instead of, like Brady, leading them into safety.
Manning was the ultimate egoist and stat padder at quarterback – a man more concerned with his image and endorsements than with winning. And it shows up in comparing his career to Tom Brady’s career. Brady was not rated as highly by the media in the 2000s because he didn’t kiss their butts for his image, but he ended up winning the war by caring more about his teammates and football. Brady won in the end.
Matthew Stafford
The revisionist history on Matthew Stafford is insane. If Todd Bowles isn’t the coach of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers and calls an inane Cover 0 with the game on the line that leads to Antoine Winfield Jr. getting burned in the NFC Championship game, the Los Angeles Rams never go to the Super Bowl and the one big accomplishment in Stafford’s career that got people to start talking about him like a Hall of Famer goes away. And Tom Brady gets one last ring that he deserved as the best player on the best team in the NFL that year. Seriously, Todd Bowles sucks.
Stafford wasn’t an innocent bystander in those awful Detroit Lions years. He was a huge part of the problem. He had loaded offenses and a really underrated defense with some hidden gems of the era like DeAndre Levy, Stephen Tulloch, Glover Quin, and Cliff Avril – not to mention the notorious Ndamukong Suh. But outside of spamming jump balls to Calvin Johnson and getting bailed out by a receiver who could have been the GOAT if he played with a better QB than Stafford during his prime, Stafford did nothing.
He was a reckless decision maker who didn’t know how to read through his progressions, he would hold the ball too long looking for the big play, and, again, he is a Peyton Manning level stat padder. Without Sean McVay giving him wide open receivers in a stacked Rams offense with even more options than Manning had in Denver and now one of the greatest WR duos in history in Puka Nacua and Davante Adams, do you really think Stafford would be stat padding his way to the MVP and then blowing all the big games?
Stafford isn’t a bad quarterback, but he’s mid. He’s not a Hall of Famer. Nobody thought that until he walked into the easiest Super Bowl MVP ever. If you don’t think Joe Flacco is HOFer – and you shouldn’t – then you shouldn’t think Stafford is either. Stafford is the ultimate example of how a supporting cast and coach can make a quarterback.
Steven Jackson
I don’t think Steven Jackson is making any all time lists, but the former St. Louis Rams running back was seen as one of the best running backs of his time when he was playing. But when I watched him, I thought he kind of stunk.
I mean, he is another guy in the fantasy football era who just a stat padder. I guess people felt bad for him because he played on some terrible Rams offenses and passing attacks, but he was honestly part of the problem, too. The guy was the definition of three yards and a cloud of dust. I can’t tell you how many times the Rams would stagnate as an offense because they would run it up the middle three times to Jackson, who would get nowhere.
Jackson mastered the art of looking like he was doing a lot on a run but getting nothing out of it, and his vision was worse than Trent Richardson’s. The man would never move laterally. He would just tuck his head down and run right into the wall of linemen over and over again. Whatever the line gave him, he got and nothing more than that. I get that the Rams were bad, but they weren’t THAT bad. And for a supposed bruising bellcow back, he only had one season with double digit rushing yards, finishing his career with 4.1 yards per carry and a rushing success rate of 45 percent.
Honestly, I think Jackson benefited from being in the beginning of the fantasy football era before people used actual analytics to evaluate players. He was a fraud and the Rams wasting their time with him for years as their No. 1 back probably contributed to them losing quite a few more games than they should have.
Cam Newton
Cam Newton had one of the best MVP seasons in NFL history in 2015, dominating through the air and on the ground as he went 15-1 and led a Carolina Panthers passing attack with such dignitaries as Kelvin Benjamin, Philly Brown, and the stone old Jericho Cotchery to the Super Bowl. Then he got embarrassed against the Denver Broncos defense, couldn’t even bother to recover a fumble and get on the ground like a real football player, and then never had a good season in his carer after that.
From the moment he stepped foot into the NFL, Newton antagonized everyone else, most famously the greatest player in his franchise’s history in Steve Smith Sr., because he thought he was all that and a slice of bread. The guy who stole a laptop and got kicked out of Florida never really grew up from his “look at me” persona, and that’s why he could never graduate into being more than just a one-hit wonder.
Newton did have a couple of other good seasons besides the 2015 one, but he was never elite besides that campaign. And again, he never got better after that. Newton had just one 4,000 yard passing season in his career, when he was a rookie, and always threw double digit interceptions in a season with a career completion percentage under 60. Outside of his MVP season, he never had an era-adjusting QB Rating+ of at least 100, and even in his MVP season, his career high was just 115. Newton was an average quarterback at his peak, below average for most of it, and benefited from playing in an era that supported offenses.
Deshaun Watson
After all the sexual assaults and both the worst trade and contract in NFL history, I doubt Deshaun Watson has many people rating him today, though he is actually winning games and not playing completely terribly for the Cleveland Browns. But it’s funny looking back on Watson, who was seen as THE darling during his time with the Houston Texans and as someone worth selling your actual soul for because he was #GoodAtTheFootballThings.
But was he that good for Houston? Because in his best season when he led the league in yards per attempt and had a QB Rating above 110 with a completion percentage of 70, the Texans were 4-12. They sucked. And you will sense a theme here of why players get overrated; he was nothing more than a simple stat padder.
And you can tell he cared more about padding stats than winning because he took a lot of sacks. His Houston offensive lines were actually pretty good, yet he led the league in sacks once, getting sent packing to the turf on 10 percent of his drop backs.
Watson benefited from throwing jump balls to a generational receiver in DeAndre Hopkins who could literally catch anything in any coverage. Are you sensing that same theme again? Otherwise, he wasn’t very accurate throwing to others and had a passing success rate well below 50 with a rather high TD:INT ratio for the era. And when you account for sacks, his yards per attempt average actually becomes below average, meaning he was making his line worse and hurting his team just to help his own numbers. Yeah, that sounds like him.
Baker Mayfield
Baker Mayfield is basically Johnny Manziel without the drug problems. He’s an overrated hot head with a bigger name than what his actual talent can cash in. He will have one great season for your franchise, get found out by defensive coordinators, and start chucking interceptions, taking bad sacks, and blaming his teammates. Remember when he threw Duke Johnson under the bust during his contract negotiations and basically said the guy didn’t want to be a part of the team because he was sick of the stupid Browns lowballing him? It’s rich coming from the same guy who invented narratives about the Carolina Panthers and Browns coaches having it out for him.
Now that he is making $55 million per year with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, he has been immediately hot garbage with all the same problems: bad throws, worse interceptions, taking sacks, and playing like he is the team. The Bucs have literally been better running it up the middle on every play than even letting him throw the ball.
But without jump balls to Mike Evans, Mayfield is nothing. Look at how he played in 2025 with and without Evans or in 2024 compared to in 2026 after Evans wisely bolted out of the Tampa Bay to San Francisco Bay. Mayfield was never good and never played the game like a real quarterback. But he’s always been overrated because there’s nothing America loves more than a fake underdog who talks a lot of trash. No wait, sorry, the only thing America loves more than that is seeing a fraud get exposed, and the rest of the NFL is definitely laughing at Tampa’s big contract mistake.
Cris Carter
Cris Carter was a great player, but a Hall of Famer? One of the best receivers of all time? I’m not so sure about that. Because Carter only had one season in his NFL career with a catch rate of 65, and he only had four seasons with 1,200 yards. In his seasons with 122 catches, he was targeted nearly 190 times, barely averaging seven yards per target.
See, Carter, by the numbers, wasn’t really a great possession receiver or playmaker. He caught a lot of passes and therefore a lot of touchdowns, but he was just a volume guy. He benefits from the fact that he happened to play in a pass happy Minnesota Vikings offense with Randy Moss taking the top off him, and Moss is probably the second best receiver in NFL history after Jerry freaking Rice.
Again, Carter was a good player, but he’s another one who got overrated because he compiled a lot of stats in a friendly offense and knew how to promote himself in the media. When you actually break down the numbers, he wasn’t even better than Jake Reed on his own team.
Brandon Marshall
Brandon Marshall is like a worse version of all the reasons Cris Carter got overrated. He was the ultimate compiler who was always a moaning diva with Jay Cutler, never won anything, and set all of his organizations years back in terms of competing because he was a financial burden. Marshall would barely catch 60 percent of what was thrown at him, and the only thing he led the league in with the Denver Broncos was targets.
He’s another guy who would compile 100 catch seasons and score a lot of touchdowns because he played in a high volume offense that would force feed him targets, mostly because it was more annoying to hear him complain about not getting the ball. He’s the ultimate example of a career loser who held his teams back because he wanted the ball over everyone else, and he made all of his teams one dimensional.
Aqib Talib
Aqib Talib loved to run his mouth and snatch chains, and while he was a good cornerback during his NFL career with multiple teams, it is telling that he was never really the best defensive back on the team. Despite being prone to getting burned and more of a gambler than a great shutdown corner in that Asante Samuel mold, Talib never had more than six interceptions in a season and never actually hit the five interception mark after leaving Tampa Bay.
He was good, but he was always overshadowed by better players and supported by being on great teams. He was half the cornerback that Chris Harris was on the Denver Broncos, and everywhere he went, he was moved on from pretty quickly once defenses and then his own team figured out that he was their weak link because he cared more about chasing numbers – that he didn’t get anyway – than actually shutting down the receiver.
Purveyor of footy since the 90s. Favor the Premier League and old school Serie A with a touch of Bundesliga. More than a touch. Professional writer for 20 years, covering every sport but now focused on the Premier League and world football. You won’t be able to guess my favorite team.